< all vehicles

Nissan X-Trail: what fails at MOT

2 generations // 2007–2021

Across 80,247 MOT tests of the Nissan X-Trail in the DfT's 2023 MOT data (initial tests, retests excluded), 25.7% failed — about 1 in 4. The parts that fail most are suspension (9.3% of tests), brakes (7.8%), lights and electrics (5.5%), tyres (5.2%) and wipers, windscreen and mirrors (3.6%).

Of the two generations, allowing for age and mileage, the X-Trail T32 (2014–2021) does best, with 3% more MOT failures than the average car of the same age and mileage. The X-Trail T31 (2007–2014) does worst, with 6% more MOT failures than the average car of the same age and mileage.

The MOT checks safety and emissions items — brakes, suspension, steering, lights, tyres, body structure and exhaust emissions. It does not test engines, gearboxes or most electronics, so those faults only show up here when they cause an emissions failure or a leak.

Nissan X-Trail MOT failures by generation
GenerationMOT testsFailedFailures vs average car, same age and mileageParts that fail most (% of tests)
X-Trail T31 (2007–2014)17,47943.7%6% moresuspension 22.8%; brakes 14.1%; lights and electrics 12.9%
X-Trail T32 (2014–2021)62,76820.7%3% morebrakes 6.1%; suspension 5.5%; tyres 5.2%
┌─ Overview ────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
Segment: mainstream
Fuel: petrol
MPG range: 40-40
Insurance group: 18-18

X-Trail T31 (2007–2014)

mainstreampetrol

MOT: 43.7% of 17,479 initial tests failed — 6% more failures than the average car of the same age and mileage

What fails most at MOT: X-Trail T31 (2007–2014)
#Part / areaShare of MOT tests failing
1suspension22.8%
2brakes14.1%
3lights and electrics12.9%
4steering10.1%
5body, chassis and structure7.5%
> Share of MOT tests failing, by mileage
suspension▁▁▃▃▄▅▆▆▇▇▇▇██▆▇█▇▇22.8%
brakes▁▂▂▃▃▄▅▅▅▆▆▆▇██▇██▆14.1%
lights and electrics▁▁▂▂▂▃▃▃▅▅▆▆▇▇▇▇▇█▆12.9%
0k100k200k+
Running
~£1562/yr (est.)
Deprec.
[HIGH]Brake lines~117k mi£80-200
[MED]Ball joints~117k mi£80-180
[MED]Brake discs~117k mi£120-280
[MED]Suspension arms~124k mi£150-350
[MED]Exhaust system~125k mi£150-400
[LOW]Brake pads~115k mi£80-160

X-Trail T32 (2014–2021)

mainstreampetrol40 mpgins. grp 18130-177 bhp0-60: 9.5s

MOT: 20.7% of 62,768 initial tests failed — 3% more failures than the average car of the same age and mileage

What fails most at MOT: X-Trail T32 (2014–2021)
#Part / areaShare of MOT tests failing
1brakes6.1%
2suspension5.5%
3tyres5.2%
4lights and electrics3.4%
5wipers, windscreen and mirrors2.9%
> Share of MOT tests failing, by mileage
brakes▁▂▃▄▄▄▄▄▄▅▅▆▅▄▄▇█6.1%
suspension▁▁▁▁▂▂▃▄▅▆▆▆▇▆▇▇█5.5%
tyres▁▂▃▄▅▆▆▇▇▇█▇█▆█▆▂5.2%
0k100k200k+
Running
~£2044/yr (est.)
Deprec.
Low mi (56k)£8.5k
Avg mi (80k)£7.9k
High mi (112k)£6.6k
[HIGH]DPF~60k mi£400-1200
[HIGH]Turbo (1.6 dCi)~80k mi£800-1400
[HIGH]Injectors (dCi)~85k mi£250-500
[MED]Ball joints~78k mi£80-180
[CRIT]CVT gearbox~70k mi£1500-3000
[LOW]Brake pads~58k mi£80-160
┌─ Known Issues to Check (estimated repair costs) ────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
[HIGH]Brake lines~117k mi£80-200
[HIGH]DPF~60k mi£400-1200
[HIGH]Turbo (1.6 dCi)~80k mi£800-1400
[HIGH]Injectors (dCi)~85k mi£250-500
[CRIT]CVT gearbox~70k mi£1500-3000

Questions

What fails most on a Nissan X-Trail at MOT?

The most common MOT failure is suspension: 9.3% of Nissan X-Trail MOT tests in the 2023 data failed on suspension. Next come brakes (7.8%) and lights and electrics (5.5%).

How often does a Nissan X-Trail fail its MOT?

25.7% of Nissan X-Trail MOT tests in the 2023 data failed (about 1 in 4), counting initial tests only, across 80,247 tests. Allowing for age and mileage, that is 4% more MOT failures than the average car of the same age and mileage.

Which Nissan X-Trail year is most reliable?

On MOT results, the X-Trail T32 (2014–2021): it has 3% more MOT failures than the average car of the same age and mileage, the best of the two generations. The X-Trail T31 (2007–2014) does worst, with 6% more MOT failures than the average car of the same age and mileage.

Does this Nissan X-Trail data cover engine and gearbox problems?

No. The MOT checks safety and emissions items — brakes, suspension, steering, lights, tyres, body structure and exhaust emissions. It does not test engines, gearboxes or most electronics, so those faults only show up here when they cause an emissions failure or a leak.

┌─ Similar Vehicles ────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
┌─ Related Articles ────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐